Fraud Horror Stories: Essential Lessons for Strengthening Internal Controls and Reducing Financial Risks

Halloween is the perfect time to explore the frightening realities of financial fraud—where trusting relationships and seemingly secure controls are sometimes not enough to protect businesses. In Centime’s recent webinar, fraud experts shared hauntingly real cases and valuable lessons on building a business that’s resilient to financial risks. Here, we dive into these powerful lessons, from identifying fraud indicators to practical steps in safeguarding your organization.

‍

1. The Real Cost of Financial Fraud: Trust Broken, Resources Lost

Fraud isn’t just about lost money; it’s a betrayal of trust and often comes at a long-term cost to businesses and communities. The nonprofit fraud case discussed by our experts shows how unchecked fraud, when left undetected, can siphon off funds for years, costing the organization nearly $565,000. Or consider the small town that lost $50 million over several years to fraud—leaving a lasting impact on the community.

‍

Takeaway: Recognize that fraud can stay hidden for years. Regularly reviewing and refreshing your internal controls, even when nothing seems amiss, can be the difference between early detection and massive loss.

‍

2. Internal Controls: Your First Line of Defense Against Fraud

To combat fraud effectively, businesses need to go beyond basic controls. Key practices like dual authorization, mandatory vacation policies, and regular role rotation serve as both deterrents and safeguards. It’s crucial to avoid complacency: every team member should be aware of the importance of these controls and the value of accountability. Fraud examiner Dawn Brolin emphasized that strong controls protect not only the organization but also its employees, shielding them from suspicion.

‍

Takeaway: Use internal controls not just to protect against fraud but also to promote trust and transparency within the organization. Regularly educate employees on why these measures exist.

‍

3. Unmasking Early Warning Signs of Fraud

Certain behaviors often accompany fraud. Reluctance to take time off, consistently working late, or unusual closeness to financial processes can all indicate the need for further scrutiny. Rotating duties and requiring regular vacations are simple yet effective ways to disrupt potential schemes.

‍

Takeaway: Even trusted employees benefit from checks and balances. Be vigilant about unusual behavior patterns, and consider small policy changes—such as mandatory time off—as a first step to safeguarding resources.

‍

4. Advanced Fraud Strategies: Getting Ahead of the Fraudsters

Fraudsters are constantly innovating, finding new ways to breach controls and exploit weaknesses. From first-party credit card bust-outs to fake vendor setups, the tactics are varied and sophisticated. One strategy shared in the webinar involved fraudsters using real identities alongside fake vendor accounts to build up credit limits undetected over months—only to suddenly cash out and disappear.

‍

Takeaway: Implement layered controls to manage high-risk areas like AP and credit issuance. Regularly review vendors and conduct surprise audits on new or less familiar vendors to prevent fake or duplicate accounts from slipping through.

‍

5. Centime’s AP Automation Solution: A Built-in Defense System

For added security, a comprehensive AP automation tool like Centime’s offers controls like dual authorization, invoice matching, and real-time transaction monitoring to catch discrepancies early. By adding layers of protection, automation helps businesses reduce human error and establish tighter security around high-risk processes.

‍

Takeaway: With AP automation, businesses can simplify control mechanisms, ensuring early detection of discrepancies and minimizing exposure to fraud risks.

‍

Conclusion

Financial fraud is more than just a Halloween scare—it’s a real threat that requires diligence, layered controls, and a proactive approach to risk management. While we’ve outlined essential strategies, there’s more to uncover. For an in-depth look at real cases and expert advice on building a fraud-resistant organization, watch Centime’s full webinar on fraud horror stories here. Dive into the full discussion for a complete understanding of these issues and actionable steps to protect your business from lurking financial threats.

Sign up for our newsletter
to get finance insights and cash planning tips delivered straight to your inbox twice per week.

**Deposit placement through ICS is subject to the terms, conditions, and disclosures in the applicable agreements. Although deposits are placed in increments that do not exceed the FDIC standard maximum deposit insurance amount (“SMDIA”) at any one destination bank, a depositor’s balances at the institution that places deposits may exceed the SMDIA (e.g., before settlement for deposits or after settlement for withdrawals) or be uninsured (if the placing institution is not an insured bank). The depositor must make any necessary arrangements to protect such balances consistent with applicable law and must determine whether placement through ICS satisfies any restrictions on its deposits. A list identifying IntraFi network banks appears at https://www.intrafi.com/network-banks. The depositor may exclude banks from eligibility to receive its funds. IntraFi and ICS are registered service marks, and IntraFi Cash Service is a service mark, of IntraFi Network LLC.

^††3.5% Annual Percentage Yield (APY) as of 11/19/24. Deposit rate may adjust to current market rate and may change daily. Fees may reduce earnings.

*Centime is not a bank and is not authorized by any federal or state agency to engage directly in core banking activities.
‍
*All banking products and services available through Centime are provided by FNBO and are governed by the applicable agreements and related disclosures provided to you by FNBO. Member FDIC.
‍
‍*While Centime facilitates traditional banking activities (such as the acceptance of deposits or extensions of credit), these services are actually provided by our banking partner, FNBO.
‍
*Centime may provide support services to FNBO, as permitted by applicable law, to facilitate the delivery of its bank products and services.

**Deposit placement through ICS is subject to the terms, conditions, and disclosures in the applicable agreements. Although deposits are placed in increments that do not exceed the FDIC standard maximum deposit insurance amount (“SMDIA”) at any one destination bank, a depositor’s balances at the institution that places deposits may exceed the SMDIA (e.g., before settlement for deposits or after settlement for withdrawals) or be uninsured (if the placing institution is not an insured bank). The depositor must make any necessary arrangements to protect such balances consistent with applicable law and must determine whether placement through ICS satisfies any restrictions on its deposits. A list identifying IntraFi network bank

Fraud Horror Stories: Essential Lessons for Strengthening Internal Controls and Reducing Financial Risks

You may also like

What is Positive Pay? A Guide to Protecting Your Business Against Fraud

7 Benefits of Cash Flow Forecasting for SMBs

Solutions

Features

Pricing

Integrations

Resources

Software Solutions

Company

Industries

Compare

Guides